Frustrated with your VA Rating?
It’s time to RUCK UP!

Understanding the 5 10 20 Year Rule for VA Disability: A Comprehensive Guide

Understanding the 5 10 20 Year Rule for VA Disability: A Comprehensive Guide

Navigating the intricacies of the 5 10 20 Year Rule for VA Disability is crucial for veterans. In this guide, we’ll break down the three key rules and provide examples to help veterans understand their rights and protections.

1. What is the 5 10 20 Year Rule VA Disability?

The VA 5 10 20 Year Rule is a set of regulations that dictate when and how the VA can reevaluate and potentially reduce a veteran’s disability rating. Here are the three critical rules:

VA Disability 5 Year Rule:

  • Purpose: Allows the VA to reevaluate your disability rating within 5 years of the initial examination if improvement is expected.
  • Exceptions:
    • Permanent and Total (P&T) Ratings: Exempt from the 5-year rule.
    • Conditions Not Expected to Improve: Veterans with permanent, unchanging conditions are also exempt.

VA Disability 10 Year Rule:

  • Purpose: Prohibits the VA from eliminating a rating in place for 10 years.
  • Exceptions:
    • Fraud: The rating can be eliminated if based on fraud.
    • P&T Ratings: Exempt from the 10-year rule.
    • Conditions Not Expected to Improve: Veterans with permanent conditions are exempt.

VA Disability 20 Year Rule:

  • Purpose: Safeguards ratings held for 20 years; they can’t be reduced below the lowest rating in the previous 20 years.
  • Exceptions:
    • Fraud: The rating can be eliminated after 20 years if based on fraud.
    • P&T Ratings: Exempt from the 20-year rule.
    • Conditions Not Expected to Improve: Veterans with permanent conditions are exempt.

2. Examples Illustrating the Rules:

Example 1: VA Disability 5 Year Rule

  • Scenario: Service-connected GERD rated at 30% for the past 3 years.
  • Rule Application: The VA may schedule a Routine Future Examination (RFE) after 5 years to assess improvement.

Example 2: VA Disability 10 Year Rule

  • Scenario: PTSD rated at 70% for the past 11 years, showing material improvement.
  • Rule Application: The VA can reduce the rating from 70% to 50% due to improvement, even after 10 years.

Example 3: VA Disability 20 Year Rule

  • Scenario: Migraine Headaches rated at 50% for the past 22 years, previously at 30%.
  • Rule Application: Even with improvement, the VA can’t reduce the rating below 30% due to the 20-year rule.

3. Protected VA Ratings Not Subject to Reexamination:

  • Ratings based on fraud
  • Permanent and Total (P&T) Ratings
  • Conditions deemed not expected to improve
  • Ratings in effect for 10 years or more
  • Ratings continuously in effect for 20 years or more
  • Veterans over 55 years of age (with exceptions)
  • 100% VA ratings deemed total disabilities
  • Ratings at the schedular minimum or 10% or less
  • Combined evaluation that wouldn’t change after reevaluation

4. Why Does the VA Reevaluate Ratings?

The VA conducts reexaminations to assess if conditions have improved, worsened, or remained the same. Not all disabilities are permanent, and the VA aims to ensure accurate and fair ratings.

5. Responding to Proposed VA Rating Reduction:

  • If proposed reduction, respond within 60 days.
  • Provide medical evidence showing no improvement.
  • Letters from treating physicians, relevant medical reports, and evidence are essential.

Understanding these rules empowers veterans to navigate the VA disability system effectively. Regular communication with healthcare providers and timely responses to VA communications are crucial elements of maintaining accurate disability ratings.

Share Now
Frustrated With Your VA Rating? It’s Time To RUCK UP!

Schedule your FREE no obligation “Discovery Call” with our Senior Coaching Officer to find out what your potential increase to your VA Disability rating could be.